Paradise for Three! – A Whimsical Tale of Love, Adventure, and Stolen Identities

Released in 1937, “Paradise for Three” (German: “Paradies für drei”) stands as a charming testament to pre-war Hollywood whimsy. Directed by the talented Rowland V. Lee, this delightful screwball comedy follows the escapades of three individuals who find themselves unexpectedly entangled in a web of mistaken identities and romantic pursuits against the backdrop of a sun-drenched tropical island paradise.

The film boasts a stellar cast, with the luminous Alice Faye portraying the alluring socialite Carol Lansing. Opposite her is the dashing and roguishly charming James Dunn as the ambitious writer, Johnny. Rounding out the trio is the ever-reliable comedian, Joe Penner, who brings his signature brand of slapstick humor to the role of the hapless inventor, Oscar.

The plot kicks off with a series of amusing misunderstandings. Carol Lansing, tired of her monotonous life and yearning for adventure, impulsively decides to embark on a luxurious cruise ship voyage. Unbeknownst to her, Johnny, seeking inspiration for his latest novel, is also aboard the same ship. Their paths cross amidst a flurry of awkward encounters and flirtations, setting the stage for an unpredictable romance.

Meanwhile, Oscar, with dreams of inventing a groundbreaking new machine, finds himself accidentally stowed away on the same vessel. His presence adds a further layer of chaos to the already volatile situation, as his eccentric inventions and cluelessness continually disrupt Carol and Johnny’s budding relationship.

Upon reaching the idyllic island paradise, the trio discovers that their initial plans have gone awry. Carol, disguised as a glamorous socialite named “Mrs. Van Der Meer,” attempts to escape her mundane life. Johnny, captivated by Carol’s allure, desperately tries to win her affections while struggling with writer’s block. And Oscar, with his comical contraptions and endless enthusiasm, unintentionally throws wrenches into both their plans.

The film seamlessly weaves together elements of romance, comedy, and adventure. The tropical setting serves as a vibrant backdrop for the unfolding chaos, with scenes showcasing sun-drenched beaches, lush jungles, and lively island festivities.

The comedic timing is impeccable, with Joe Penner’s physical humor and witty one-liners providing ample laughter. Alice Faye’s captivating screen presence perfectly embodies Carol Lansing’s blend of vulnerability and determination, while James Dunn’s portrayal of Johnny captures the charming awkwardness of a writer struggling to find his voice both in love and literature.

“Paradise for Three” is more than just a lighthearted comedy; it delves into themes of identity, social expectations, and the search for happiness. Carol Lansing’s desire to escape her life as a wealthy socialite highlights the societal pressures and limitations faced by women in that era. Johnny’s struggle with writer’s block reflects the universal challenge of creative expression.

The film’s production values are noteworthy, with stunning cinematography capturing the allure of the tropical island setting. The costumes are elegant and stylish, reflecting the glamorous lifestyle of the characters.

The musical score is equally delightful, featuring catchy tunes that complement the comedic moments and romantic interludes. “Paradise for Three” is a delightful throwback to the golden age of Hollywood, offering audiences a timeless tale of love, laughter, and adventure.

Its enduring appeal lies in its ability to transport viewers to a simpler time, where escapism and entertainment reigned supreme. Whether you’re a fan of classic comedies or simply seeking a feel-good cinematic experience, “Paradise for Three” is sure to leave you smiling long after the credits roll.